Death Event without Date

Help
1

I am using GrampsAIO64 6.0.3 with Windows 11.
When I have a person with a birth event and the birth was a long time ago, I have entered a death event without a date.
This procedure worked in the last versions. In version 6.0.3, when I check the data, I now get the message “Invalid death date.”
For an empty death event, the following data was generated in the old version (5.2.4)

‘’’ Source

Death

‘’’ Source

In the new version (6.0.3), the following data is generated:

'‘’ Source

Death


‘’’ Source

Is this an error or am I doing something wrong?

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

2

I can see that the information in the source is not displayed correctly. The entries in the new version have a VAL=“” entry, whereas the old version does not.

3

Welcome!

In Gramps, it is not necessary to add an empty Death event to signify a person has died.

There is a setting on the Preferences Limits tab: Maximum age probably alive: Default: 110.

Without a known death event, Gramps will assume the person has died 110 years after their birth year. You can alter this setting.

4

It is not necessary but it should be possible.

1 Like
5

And users can enter a non-dated death record. Verify data will highlight either invalid events with no date, or an extremely old person with no death record.

There is a difference between Gramps having an understanding that a person is probably deceased for reports, etc. Verify data is for the user’s use to highlight issues within the data and may need more work.

1 Like
6

If I remove the disputed death event, there is no longer any dispute and the exported GEDCOM file does not contain a death event, as expected.

How can I create a death event “1 DEAT Y” in GEDCOM, preferably without any disputes when checking the data, as it worked in the old versions?

7

@Nick-Hall Is this issue related to a comment you made in a recent bux fix PR that “we should update the Check and Repair tool to fix any date field containing None?”

Not necessarily the repair tool, but handling of dates containing None?

8

I agree. I recently started doing this, but have not yet upgraded to 6.0, so I hope it will continue to work.

Yes, if they have a birth date (or if some other logic catches them). I had many people that fell through the cracks as being “probably alive” even though they were from many generations ago, so I started entering undated Death events for them.

9

Regarding GEDCOM: if there is no date (DATE), and no place (PLAC) , and no source (SOUR) known, you should use „1 DEAT Y“, otherwise „1 DEAT“.

In GEDCOM 7 there is now the „NO“ event; if you know for sure that a very old person is still alive at a specific date, you can specify that using the „NO“ event.

1 Like
10

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.